We’ve all had to deal with the annoyance of a dog that won’t stop barking. When it’s a large dog like a German Shepherd, it might not be as simple as telling the dog to “shut up.” Although no one wants to hurt a barking dog, it is necessary to deter this behavior by one means or another.
One of the more effective ways to do this is through the use of an anti-bark collar. These collars use a variety of means to discourage barking, such as noise, vibration, or static shock. Let’s take a look at seven of the best anti-bark collars that we could find.
1. Patpet Dog Shock Collar with Remote
This one is a true shock collar, as it uses static shock to discourage unwanted barking and other behaviors. Some people consider these collars to be cruel and/or unsafe, but their voltage is no worse than a random charge of static electricity. For a large dog like a German Shepherd, there is no real reason to be concerned.
One of the best things about this model is its long-range capabilities. When correctly paired with the remote, this device can do its job up to 1000 feet away. Of course, you will seldom need to use it from this distance, but it’s good to know that you can do so.
This one also seems to be pretty durable without adding a whole lot of weight. That’s good because heavier collars will irritate a dog, making it more likely that the collar will be slipped, chewed, etc. On that same subject, we like the silicone-covered prongs for the added comfort that they provide.
This is the most expensive collar on our list, although the margin isn’t very large. Our only real complaint comes from the process of pairing the collar with its remote. This process is a little bit complex and confusing and often requires multiple tries to get it right.
- Very long range
- Customized levels of static shock
- Prongs are made of soft silicone
- Charges in only 2 hours
- Parts are thick and durable
- A little expensive
- Collar and remote are difficult to pair
2. Stopwoofer Humane Dog Bark Collar
This one is meant to be a more human alternative to the shock collar. Instead of using electricity, it uses a mixture of noise and vibration to discourage the dog. In some ways, this might be compared to a verbal reminder from their master, as it is just a verbal chastisement. At the most, it might cause a little discomfort to their sensitive ears, but not enough to cause any harm.
The adjustable sensitivity is a plus, as it helps to eliminate the problem of false positives. You can’t have a device like this making false corrections because that will only confuse the animal. The sensor on this device is meant to detect barking and nothing else.
Perhaps one of the best things about this collar is its long battery life. Once it has been charged, you won’t have to bother with it for about two weeks. Of course, that is the battery life under optimal conditions.
Our only real issue with this product is the fact that its receiver is so large. It hinders a dog’s balance when there is something heavy around its neck. While the price is reasonable, the weight is not.
- Causes no pain
- Adjustable sensitivity
- The battery lasts up to 2 weeks on a full charge
- Uses both sound and vibration
- Easy to charge from any USB port
- Somewhat large and heavy
- May not deter a large and stubborn dog
3. K9 Konnection Smart Bark Collar for Dogs
This is probably the best product on our list in terms of waterproofing. The whole thing is made to resist a much greater degree of submersion than other models, making it a perfect choice for dogs that like to swim.
This is one of the most versatile collars that we have seen. It can use shock, sound, vibration, or a combination of the above. Depending on which setting you use, this one can be made to use gentle methods first, going to the static shock if the dog doesn’t listen.
Like our previous choice, this collar only needs about two hours of charge, and that will last for up to two weeks. It can be plugged into any device with a USB port, making it easy to keep it going. We also like the money-back guarantee, as that gives the customer a little more confidence in the product.
The complaints about this model are minor ones, but should still be mentioned. The receiver is kind of large, and it tends to ride in the front. That means that the prongs are right at the dogs’ throat. This is also one of the more expensive choices on our list.
- Firmly waterproofed
- Can use sound, vibration, and shock
- Lasts 2 weeks on a 2-hour charge
- Suitable for dogs of all sizes
- Money-back guarantee
- A little expensive
- A little bit bulky
4. Dog Care Dog Bark Collar
This is one of the more visually attractive models on our list, as it looks kind of like something out of a science fiction movie. The sleek and streamlined appearance is a big improvement over many bark collars that we have seen. Instead of a large awkward box around their neck, the dog gets a collar that is only slightly larger than normal.
Like many of the better options in this category, this collar uses a mix of shock, sound, and vibration to do its job.
However, it mostly relies on a static shock to provide the necessary deterrent. The multiple indicator lights give you a way to see what mode is being used, even if you don’t already know.
We can see that this collar is made with a thin strap. This might not be strong enough for a full-grown German Shepherd, so that’s one small problem right away. Also, we can see that this collar is not very sensitive.
It takes a loud bark to set this collar off, which can create some issues with consistency. On the upside, this thing does a great job of avoiding false positives, but it also tends to miss a few of the quieter barks.
- Very sleek and nice-looking
- The receiver is not large or heavy
- Uses shock, sound, and vibration
- Multiple indicator lights
- Price is pretty low
- The strap seems a little weak
- Isn’t always triggered reliably
5. Dog Care Rechargeable Dog Training Collar
This is another product that combines multi-functionality with a compact and lightweight receiver. Although it’s one of the more expensive items on our list, it does offer a high degree of quality.
This remote has a range of up to 1000 feet. Again, you will only get that kind of range under optimal conditions, but you will seldom need to correct your dog from that distance anyway. We also like that thick nylon strap, which looks like it can handle a lot of abuse.
One of the best features of this product is the keypad lock on the remote. With some products of this type, it can be very easy to accidentally shock your dog because your hand slipped and hit the button. With this remote, you can lock out the keypad and prevent these accidents from occurring.
As for the downsides, there are a couple of them. Aside from the high price, this product has a remote that is somewhat hard to use. You will undoubtedly have to spend a little more time getting used to this one. What’s more, some customers have said that this collar did a poor job of resisting water.
- Remote has a range of up to 1000 ft
- Not very large or awkward
- Secured by a thick nylon strap
- 100 levels of shock adjustment
- Remote has a keypad lock
- Remote is hard to use
- Some customers have reported durability issues
6. DogRook Bark Collar
You couldn’t ask for a simpler product than this one. It doesn’t have any fancy gimmicks and it doesn’t do any special tricks. In fact, it doesn’t even use an electric charge. This one is meant for those who need a gentler solution, as it uses only sound and vibration to do its job.
We like the fact that they kept things small with this one. The receiver box isn’t going to be a burden for your dog or an eyesore for you. In fact, this one is quite easy to ignore. We like the fact that it’s fully waterproof, as this feature is quite essential on a product of this type.
The strap looks to be large enough for most German Shepherds, but we do have some issues with the clasp that holds it in place. This is just a thin piece of plastic, and we do not think it is sufficient to hold a large and muscular dog. Also, sound and vibration alone won’t always be enough to get your point across.
- Very easy to use
- Fully waterproof for outdoor use
- Receiver box is very small
- Large enough for most German Shepherds
- Uses only sound and vibration
- Collar clasp is too weak
- May not deter the stubborn cases
7. Authen Bark Collar Barking Control Training Collar
This is another good choice for an anti-bark collar, and this one is very ambitious in its design. It uses all three methods of correction (sound, vibration, and shock), but it does so in a highly intelligent way. All three of the correction modes can be customized in many ways.
More to the point, this one has an “intelligent protection” mode that is meant to provide a proportional response to your dog’s barking. For instance, the first time it’s triggered, it will use a very gentle reminder. However, as the barking grows more intense, the correction will also get a little more intense.
We are a little concerned about this feature, to be honest. Although it might take some of the work out of your hands, it also removes some of the control. For safety reasons, we think it’s better to maintain close control of a device like this.
Even if there are no safety issues, the overcomplicated nature of this device could make it more likely to malfunction.
- Correction type is highly customizable
- Made to reduce false triggering
- The strap is thick and durable
- Intelligent protection mode
- Quick to charge, fairly long life
- Prongs are a little too large
- Over-complexity could cause malfunctions
Best Bark Collar for German Shepherds Buyer’s Guide
In the above section, you can see some specific examples of good anti-bark collars. Any of these products would be sufficient for a German Shepherd, but there is no way that we can make the best choice without your input. That’s why you should look at our advice as a set of suggestions rather than a book of rules.
Now that you understand things a little better, let’s consider the most important factors that you should consider when buying an anti-bark collar.
As you may have noticed, anti-bark collars come in many forms, and some forms are a little harsher than others. As a general rule, you should not use any more force than necessary when you are disciplining a dog.
The point is not to cause pain, but to get your point across. When choosing a bark collar for your German Shepherd, you will need to think about the size of the dog, and also how stubborn that dog might be.
If you have a timid dog that is easily scared, you should stay away from the shock collars. Stick with something that uses a gentle vibration or a loud noise.
On the other hand, dogs with a rowdy and knuckleheaded nature might require a little more of a jolt to get their attention. Either way, you need to choose a collar that suits the level of intensity that your animal requires.
Size And Weight
Another thing that you want to avoid are collars that have a huge box attached to the collar. Even for a large dog like a German Shepherd, this kind of thing is very uncomfortable. Before you strap that big brick to your dog’s neck, you should ask yourself how you would feel about wearing that thing!
That being said, an anti-bark collar is always going to be a little bulkier than a normal collar. You should expect this to be the case, but try to hold it down as much as possible. Your dog will be much happier for the effort.
Ease Of Use
When it comes down to it, this is really a simple device. It is just a tool that produces an unpleasant consequence when your dog breaks the rules. Yes, there is some technology behind it, but that doesn’t matter for the average user. All you need to know is how it works.
You would think that a remote for an anti-bark collar would be quite simple. It only needs one button, although there are plenty of other features that you might find to be helpful. Still, some manufacturers have gone way overboard with this idea.
When you are looking at the remote that goes with your anti-bark collar, you will want to look for one that is self-explanatory. There shouldn’t be a learning curve, and you shouldn’t have to read an entire manual. You should at least be able to pick up the remote and make it work with no hassle.
A Durable Strap And Clasp
Needless to say, these collars are a little more expensive than most others. As such, you want to make sure that they don’t fall off and get lost. To keep this from happening, you need to choose an anti-bark collar with a strong and well-secured strap.
Although there are many options, your best choices will usually be made of leather or nylon. Both of these materials are durable, inexpensive, and long-lived. Apart from the materials, you need a strap that is at least as thick as your thumb. German Shepherds are pretty powerful animals, so you cannot make do with a thin strap.
The clasp is actually the most important part of the collar (at least in terms of durability). If it fails, everything fails, so take a close look at that clasp before putting your money on the counter. A clasp made of thin plastic is not going to last very long and could cause you to lose the collar itself.
If you are looking at an anti-bark collar, and it doesn’t seem to be waterproof, you should probably look elsewhere. While it might be a special feature for some products, waterproofing is a must for something like this. Dogs have a tendency to get into all sorts of messes, and their collar will always be along for the ride.
It isn’t enough for the collar to just be “water-resistant.” This term is often used quite loosely, so you can’t always trust that a “water-resistant” product will have the durability that you need. A collar of this type should be able to withstand a dip in the water with no trouble. Every gap should be sealed, and every surface should be coated.
Although there is not always a need for versatility, it’s good to give yourself plenty of options. Dogs have a way of doing the unexpected, so you should be prepared for whatever may come. If nothing else, you may want to re-use a particular collar for a different dog.
All of this comes down to one thing: You should look for a collar that gives you more than one correction mode. The greater your ability to customize the training, the more likely it is that your dog will respond to that training.
Look For Some Kind Of Guarantee
These collars are not massively expensive, but you should still look for one that offers a money-back guarantee. Ideally, you would want to have a full manufacturer’s warranty with a term of at least 2 years. Of course, this is the ideal situation, and you won’t usually find such a generous guarantee on an anti-bark collar.
Even if you never plan to take advantage of that “money-back guarantee,” it is still a good thing to see. When a company stands behind their product, it means that you are probably going to get a higher level of safety and a little more quality control.
As frustrating as it can be, a barking dog is not particularly hard to silence. It just takes a little bit of consistency and the right kind of training. Since modern science has given us a new and effective correction tool, we would be foolish not to take advantage of its benefits.
We hope that this article has given you a good grasp of the subject and that you will now be able to make an informed decision.